The witch finger cookies are good... but I found that not many people ate them the first couple of years I made them because not many people care much for shortbread cookies these days. Then I changed the recipe to a snicker doodle cookie. The last batch I made ALL got eaten for the first time ever.
Those are great pictures! I always have a ton of food leftover too. Of course, it doesn't stop me from overdoing it every year..lol