I really love the idea of the winners circle photo album! HOW AMAZING! From 1987?!?!?! That is just fantastic! It would be great to see the costumes evolve throughout the years.
I usually make about 20-25 goody bags for my Adult Halloween party. They consist of a biohazard bag filled with test tube liquor shots, those cool pens that look like syringe's, good candy, a balloon, maybe a temp tattoo or sticker, and some other cheep toy I got on clearance from the year before.
My TOT's I used to use the little brown paper sacks that you'd get when you buy a 40 at the convenience store and fill them with a piece of good candy, cheap nasty candy, clearance toy, and a sticker. I got a stack of the bags from the store simply by being nice and asking if I could have some. I laid them out on some scrap wood, put an old saw blade, razors, and other random stuff on them and "dusted" them with black and red spray paint to decorate them. They dry fast and look very amazing.
I did that for a few years. Then my yard and reputation started brining more TOT's so I did the bags and chilled some of the Hugs drinks. A case for a few bucks. I'd let them choose, either the goodie bag or drink. Most of them wanted the drink. And the parents were into that idea. Last year they only got a drink.
One year while my buddy was working for a beer company he scored me a few cases of nasty beer. So when the adults would dress up with the TOTs I offered them beer and peanuts. hehe...
I tried doing prizes for the best costume at the party. Offered the Halloween wine glass, a movie, some candles, and cool skull jewelry but most of the time the winner would leave it all and I'd reuse it for the next year. HAHA Must be an ugly wine glass, ive use it for 5 Halloweens in a row.