The elevator was a dissapointment to me because it started with grand plans that ultimately failed. I then had little time to work on the realism after that. All in all, it was a great success but certainly not my scariest haunt (I think the parents liked it more than the kids). I would like to stress just how creapy fishing lures can be. Just go to a sports store and look at them. Great for making small slimy things. One thing I wanted to do but ran out of time was to rig a wheel with loose straps that would simulate some small creature scuttling across the plastic ceiling. It would start with a strange alien scream then a scuttle above their heads. Unseen can be scary. Thanks for the gore comment. I think neighborhood haunts should be scary, but not gorey. They're for the young kids, not the teenagers.
[Bows in presence of the master].
I am very impressed with your work and I do like the themes you come up with (Your fortune teller takes the cake). You also have an excellent website. When I saw your Sci-Fi man-eating plant theme, I was like "This is perfect". This is what I would be shooting for.
I too, wanted to have an elevator in my project.
Doing a haunted elevator is an ambitous project and I have not got it down pat on how I would implent it. So I always come up with ideas too, but there always is some kind of hitch with implenting the technique. Either it is a compromise or do something very expensive.
Stainless steel panels would be the most believable, but also the most expensive AND hard to work with. Your idea of using Masonite is great...it is fairly light and strong. But it's downside is that it is less believable.
My plan was to go easy on the elevator design and heavy on the illusion or effects. I wanted to have a mostly open frame elevator like the old wrought iron ones from the 20's and 30's era (but actually made of PVC). Creating the look that you were descending would be a little trick I would borrow from Disney. The main downside is that it would be a very tall prop and would have to be constructed outside or within a building with a high ceiling. Other alternatives have me coming up with something that is too expensive.
In addition to the descending illusion...would also be the fact that when the elevator doors open...you would be in a different area then where you started. This I know how to do and it is pretty easy too. But putting the two effects together is hard.
Of course there would be the standard shaking and awful sounds that would make people wish they haven't stepped foot in the thing

.
But I really want to fool people into thinking..."this seems to be a real elevator".
Perhaps we could pool our minds together on this one.
Keep up the great work. It seems every year you get better.
JG