I used cookie dough to make my witches fingers last year; probably a butter cookie/cookie press recipe so it was a little stiffer. we rolled them, squished knuckles in and then cut the knuckle wrinkles in. pressed almond slivers in red paste food coloring and used for fingernails and baked according to the cookie directions. they were a HUGE hit, I used cookie dough because it doesn't spread/rise as much as a bread dough will. "painted" blood in the finger knuckles.
really easy, it only sound hard. and good!
really easy, it only sound hard. and good!